
State’s High Court Reinstates Denial of Flight Attendant’s Uniform Claim
- The Minnesota Supreme Court on Nov. 12 reversed a Workers’ Compensation Court of Appeals decision and reinstated a compensation judge’s denial of a Delta Air Lines flight attendant’s claims that her work uniform caused occupational skin and respiratory injuries.
- The flight attendant claimed occupational diseases in November 2019 (skin) and Jan. 29, 2020 (respiratory) from Delta’s “Passport Plum” uniform, which the airline introduced to all employees in May 2018. A compensation judge found she failed to prove causation and denied the claim in full.
- The WCCA reversed on the skin injury and vacated the denial on the respiratory injury after concluding the opinion of Delta’s expert toxicologist lacked foundation.
- The Supreme Court held the WCCA erred in setting aside the expert’s opinion: “While Dr. Topliff may not have been aware of every possible fact,” the record contained evidence that a reasonable mind might accept as supporting the judge’s findings, so the WCCA should have deferred rather than substitute its own judgment.
Pennsylvania Court Changes TTD Award to TPD Under 2018 Law
- Pennsylvania’s Commonwealth Court, in a published opinion filed Nov. 16, affirmed an order by the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board that changed a worker’s benefits from temporary total disability to temporary partial disability based on an impairment rating evaluation that didn’t reach a state law threshold for a TTD award.
- Donald Ball suffered a work-related lower back injury in March 1991 and had received TTD benefits of $436 a week. An October 2023 IRE produced a 27% impairment rating, below 35% threshold under Act 111.
- Ball argued Act 111 could not apply to an injury that predated the 1996 Act 57, under which IRE provisions applied only to injuries on or after June 24, 1996.
- The court held that Act 111, enacted in 2018, contains no such temporal limitation and applies to all injuries; TPD status is limited to 500 weeks of benefits.
Court: Comp Exclusive Remedy Is a Defense, Not Immunity from Suit
- The First Court of Appeals of Texas in Houston on Nov. 13, denied a petition for writ of mandamus by United Forming Inc. and Choice Contractors LLC, which challenged a trial court’s denial of their summary-judgment motion that a case against them should be dismissed under the Texas Workers’ Compensation Act’s exclusive-remedy defense.
- The underlying suit, Mejia v. Linbeck Group LLC, is pending in Harris County’s 281st District Court. Real parties in interest include the estate of Walter Elias Sr.
- The court held the exclusive-remedy provision is “an affirmative defense to liability” that must be pleaded and proved, not an immunity from suit, so defendants have an adequate remedy by appeal after final judgment.
- The panel “respectfully” disagreed with the Fourteenth Court of Appeals’ Dec. 2025 ExxonMobil ruling and noted at least six mandamus requests by the defense since last December, saying any broader immediate review should be left to the state Legislature.
