Curated Content Articles of Interest from Around the Web

    Late Discovery Compliance Does Not Warrant Lawsuit Dismissal: Court

    new york supreme court

     

    Late Discovery Compliance ‘Doesn’t Warrant Dismissal’ of Suit

    • New York’s Appellate Division, Second Department, ruled Oct. 28 in Leader v. 85 Quay Street, LLC that a worker’s failure to comply with a discovery order in a timely fashion did not warrant dismissal of his personal injury suit. The court affirmed a Kings County Supreme Court order, which directed Jamison Leader to provide the outstanding discovery by a specified date rather than dismissing the complaint against the property owner, 85 Quay Street, LLC.
    • Leader sued in January 2020 over injuries he allegedly suffered when he fell from stairs at a construction site owned by 85 Quay. After his December 2023 deposition, 85 Quay demanded supplemental discovery, including unrestricted authorizations for prior medical treatment records and the file for a 2009 workers’ compensation claim he’d filed. A December 2024 order directed him to provide the information by Jan. 31, 2025, and said his claim would be dismissed “upon further motion” if he failed to comply.
    • The court held that striking a pleading is a drastic remedy warranted only on a clear showing that the failure to comply was willful and contumacious, and that 85 Quay had not made that showing even though Leader’s compliance was untimely.
    • Leader had earlier provided numerous authorizations for 85 Quay to access his files. Before the court ruled on 85 Quay’s motion, he provided unrestricted authorizations, with durable powers of attorney and an affidavit explaining that the treatment occurred about 15 years earlier and that he no longer recalled certain identifying details.

    READ MORE

     

    Court Grants Worker Summary Judgment on Labor Law Claim

    • A New York Appeals Court ruled Oct. 28 in Magpantay v. New York City School Construction Authority that an injured worker should have been granted summary judgment in his Labor Law claim alleging that a general contractor, the New York City School Construction Authority, and the property owner, the New York City Department of Education, had violated the law by not providing a safe workplace. The court reversed the Queens County Supreme Court’s denial on that claim but affirmed the lower court’s ruling that dismissed the worker’s personal injury allegation.
    • Bienvenido Magpantay allegedly suffered head and shoulder injuries when a 20- to 25-pound U-head fell from above at a construction site. He testified that carpenters were assembling scaffolding 30 to 45 feet above him and that no safety devices, such as netting, protected workers below.
    • The court found the evidence established an elevation-related hazard, a need to secure the U-head and a causal link between the lack of a safety device and the injuries.
    • The court affirmed the denial of summary judgment on the other claims. Testimony that objects fell in the same area about an hour earlier did not establish that workers were normally exposed to falling objects. The plaintiffs also did not show enough supervisory control by the defendants to support a Labor Law § 200 claim.

    READ MORE

     

    FedEx Skipped Required Step Before Ordering Independent Medical Exam

    • Australia’s Administrative Review Tribunal ruled Nov. 6 that FedEx Express Australia failed to follow a mandatory step before ordering a longtime courier driver to attend an independent orthopedic examination, and set aside the examination determination. The matter was sent back to FedEx for reconsideration in compliance with the Guide for Arranging Rehabilitation Assessments and Requiring Examinations 2024. The ruling does not resolve the worker’s underlying compensation claim, which remains before the Tribunal.
    • The Guide says an employer that finds its information insufficient “should” request more from the worker’s treating doctors and rely on them “as much as possible” before sending the worker to an independent specialist. FedEx argued “should” gave it a choice.
    • The Tribunal found the word was “instructional and directive,” meaning in effect “must” absent exceptional circumstances. It said that an independent examination should be considered only when all other methods of obtaining medical information have been exhausted.
    • The worker drove for FedEx for more than 30 years until osteoarthritis in his hands, knees, right hip and spine made it hard to finish a shift, and he lodged a claim under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. FedEx, with his consent, obtained information from his treating doctors and had him examined by a rheumatologist, after which it denied the claim.
    • FedEx had written to the worker’s doctor in May 2024, before the Guide took effect in September 2024. It did not go back to any treating doctor afterward, including the treating orthopedic surgeon, whose records covered pain in multiple locations from osteoarthritis, or the rheumatologist or vascular surgeon involved in his care.

    READ MORE