
Utah Firefighters with Cancer Denied Benefits under New Presumption Law
- West Jordan, Utah, firefighter and paramedic Justin Young filed a workers’ comp claim April 30 after his prostate cancer returned. After 111 days, Travelers denied it because his cancer was first discovered before the presumption’s July 1 effective date.
- Utah lawmakers in 2025 expanded a law presuming certain cancers, including prostate cancer, are work-related for firefighters. Insurers generally have 21 days to decide a claim, or 45 days if an investigation is required. A Utah Labor Commission spokesman said patient privacy issues slowed Young’s case and carriers aren’t strictly held to the deadlines when good cause exists.
- Travelers said it determined “the statutory presumption does not apply” to Young’s claim and will reevaluate if it receives new information. Rep. Casey Snider, R-Paradise, who sponsored the expansion, said he has heard of 30 to 40 firefighters caught in the coverage gap.
- Snider and Rep. Jordan Teuscher, R-South Jordan, said lawmakers plan to address the gap next session. A Firefighter Cancer Benefit Trust Fund created in 2026 has yet to pay benefits; its board must send recommendations to lawmakers before Dec. 1.
Montana High Court Upholds Violation but Voids Comp Insurer’s $25,000 Fine
- The Montana Supreme Court ruled Nov. 10 that the Montana-based workers’ comp insurer Victory Insurance Co. violated state Insurance Code by refusing to disclose a federal lawsuit in its 2021 annual statement.
- Clear Spring Property and Casualty Co., which bought Victory’s book of workers’ comp policies in 2019 and kept Victory as its managing general agent, sued Victory in March 2021 seeking more than $8 million. The case settled in April 2022.
- The court said the commissioner’s staff directed Victory four times to amend the statement, yet Victory declined. The commissioner could not order disclosure of the settlement, which fell outside the reporting period, but that “does not give Victory carte blanche to ignore all Commissioner directives,” Justice Ingrid Gustafson wrote.
- The court reversed the maximum $25,000 fine because the agency gave no explanation for the amount and sent the case back for the agency to “cogently explain” its choice before imposing any fine.
Court Upholds Denial of Nurse’s Long COVID Claim Amendment
- New York’s Appellate Division, Third Department, on Nov. 12 affirmed a Workers’ Compensation Board decision barring a registered nurse from amending her established COVID-19 claim against Good Samaritan Hospital to include Long COVID.
- A workers’ comp judge, in Hahnenfeld v. Good Samaritan Hospital, established her claim for contracting COVID-19 at work in April 2020 and later amended it to include Long COVID. The board reversed in a May 2025 amended decision, finding insufficient evidence that her symptoms were causally related to the work-related infection.
- The court noted the board’s position that long-term symptoms of an established COVID-19 claim are compensable without amending the claim, while discrete consequential conditions must be separately proven by the claimant.
- Writing for the court, Justice Corcoran said the physicians were unaware of the timing of the nurse’s second COVID-19 infection, which occurred around December 2021. The nurse also reported other medical conditions, so substantial evidence supported the board’s decision.
